Mifare classic copy issues

Hmmmmm, Is your card definitely a Mifare 1k or is it a 4k or other?
How many bytes is your (N)UID?
eg
4 bytes 01:02:03:04
7 bytes 01:02:03:04:05:06:07

Did you follow these videos?

Can you share a TagInfo report? Obfuscate your UID for security if you like.

Do you happen to have a Proxmar3 also?