Proxmark3 cloning fob with two types

Hello all, the other day I tried cloning a fob that read back as both HID and Indala. Attempted to copy both onto a generic lf fob, and was able to clone the Indala successfully, but the HID seemed to kill the fob. It would no longer recognize it after the clone. I tried using all methods. including trying to use the binary.
I’m assuming it’s because I didn’t use a T55x7, Q5/T5555 or EM4305/4469 like it recommended? Also I’m very new to this and haven’t encountered a fob with two types, two card numbers, facility codes etc. yet. Am I able with the right fob to just clone both one after the other? Any insight is appreciated, pictures and pm3 logs attached, cheers.
Running Proxmark3 Easy with appropriate software.

download (1)
download (2)

you can’t overwrite these fobs. they’re read only. you need to use a t5577/em4305

when cloning you only need to clone the HID as the indala is just a response to raw data