Simulating LF cards with the Proxmark

Hi All,

Y’all have managed to solve my past RFID issues so figured I’d come back again. Currently trying to simulate an LF card (Kantech IoProx) with the Proxmark3 but not getting any response from the reader when I do. Normally, when I present an ioprox card to the reader (even an invalid one) it will beep indicating something has been detected, however, in this case no indication that the card has been detected.

I’ve been successfully able to clone cards to a T5577 chip and my NeXT implant so I know the LF functions on the Promark are working.

The command I’m running is:

lf io sim --vn 2 --fc 88 --cn 33190

Appreciative if there any Proxmark wizards out there who can help.

Hello, (Not a certified wizard sorry) I note that the ioProx section of the Proxmark guide includes read and clone commands, but not sim, whereas other card types do include a sim section.
So I’d suggest it may not be supported

Edit:
Here is the post of the team who first added the support for that card in 2014 - Given the elapsed time since then and the fact that it’s a propietry format I’d say the sim functionality is too difficult to implement or it would be there.

1 Like

Interesting, thanks for tracking that down. Odd that the help menu shows sim as an option. C’est la vie.

Waiting for an LF HID reader to arrive and I’ll try my hand at SIMing those

Well I’m no programmer, but from what I interperate;
The help function of some cards contains a line to “clear buffer” before display the help options,
see line 2218 below

However the help command for lfio cards looks like this

On line 176 you can see it just jumps straight into reading the options (ie CommandTable)

and from lines 161 to 165 you can see Sim just shouldn’t be there.

Weird, when I run lf io help I get a totally different set of options:

[usb] pm3 --> lf io help
help             this help
demod            demodulate an ioProx tag from the GraphBuffer
reader           attempt to read and extract tag data
clone            clone ioProx tag to T55x7 or Q5/T5555
sim              simulate ioProx tag
watch            continuously watch for cards. Reader mode

and running the sim command results in it actually trying to do something:

usb] pm3 --> lf io sim --vn 2 --fc 01 --cn 22899
[+] Simulating ioProx version: 2 FC: 1 (0x01) CN: 22899
[+] Press pm3-button to abort simulation or run another command
[+] IO raw bits:
[+]  0000000001111000010000000110000001010101100110111001110100000011 

[#] FSK simulating with rf/64, fc high 10, fc low 8, STT 1, n 4100
[=] You can cancel this operation by pressing the pm3 button
[=] Done

Wonder if I’ve cloned down a different repository or something. Mine was cloned from https://github.com/RfidResearchGroup/proxmark3.git

That is the current Iceman Repo and here is the appropriate command list from it…

As can be seen lf io sim is perfectly acceptable.

so “in theory” it should work?

Is this potentially a limitation of the Proxmark3 Easy vs the Proxmark3?

I don’t think hardware version will have anything to do with it… commands run the same on each if the firmware is compiled for the right hw version… but… I mean… you are holding the LF antenna to the reader right? hahh sorry, had to ask :slight_smile:

And not shorting the Proxmark3 out, and have entered the right parameters to actually simulate a card?

Yep My bad, I forgot Iceman Repo was not the only one and when I went searching I got the wrong one!

That is the new Iceman Repo. It moved.

Thanks for all the replies guys.

I’m holding the Proxmark directly in front of the reader, and slowly moving it up and down but not getting any response from the reader itself. The reader is a Kantech P225 if it makes a difference. The range on the reader is pretty good with my NeXT - I can basically hold my hand a couple inches away in any orientation and get a read, winder if the Proxmark is significantly more finnicky?

When running the simulation I’m using values identical to the values I used when cloning to a T5577 card, so I believe they should be correct.

@Zwack not sure what you mean by shorting out the Proxmark? I’ve been holding it by the edges of the PCB, should I be grabbing it in a different position?

Thanks again for all the advice guys!

Holding it by the edge should be good. The LF antenna is attached to the main board by the metal pillars in the middle. If you were bridging across there it has the potential to short out the antenna.

Just to tag on to my own thread here, I had a chance to do a bit of experimenting today and validated I was able to simulate HID cards no issue (tested against a ProxPro II reader), however, it seems there may be a coupling issue with the IOProx readers.

I did manage to get a successful simulation to a P325W26 reader at the office (which is a Wiegand version), however, no such luck getting a read on the P225XSF reader I have at home. Not sure if the difference has to do with the Wiegand vs XSF data format or if it has to do with the antenna differences (the 325 is physically larger and rated for 20cm read distance vs 16cm on the 225). I’ll try and track down a P325XSF to rule out one possibility.

Even on the 325 it’s extremely finicky to get the Proxmark to couple, needs to be in exactly the right position at exactly the right angle. Definitely more difficult then I was expecting it to be.