Starfield is fantastic IMO.
The biggest problem with the public perception is that too many people went into it expecting a space sim or space exploration game (no thanks to the way that Todd Howard presented it), while itās still an RPG at its core. Oblivion in space is a good way to put it, although thatās purely in mechanics. The setting feels incredibly fresh. People compare it to No Manās Sky or Elite Dangerous (or Star Citizen, which is barely functionalā¦), when thatās extremely disingenuous to me. Starfield has SO much story content and so many quest lines, with pretty good voice acting. Everything is pretty curated, although thereās also plenty of generated bases and such to explore if youād like to go that route. Itās just a different genre.
I purposefully avoided any kind of info beforehand, and just jumped in when it released.
The space dogfighting is pretty good, and given that you can jump/travel from your ship itself (a lot of people donāt realize this, you use the scanner), itās still pretty immersive to go from place to place.
There are tons of interesting side quests, and a lot of interesting continuity and interactions (a lot of side quests affect interactions in other places).
Iām ~40 hours in, by far the most Iāve played any video game in the last few years. I still havenāt gone too in-depth with outposts, ship building, etc. Finished up the main quest at ~30 hours, and just going through side quests now having a ton of fun. Still have a lot of lore left uncovered.
It really feels like the internet is just searching for outrage at this point, a lot of the people who Iāve seen shitting on it havenāt played it one bit, and are just repeating whatever theyāve read online.
Iāve had a few minor bugs, but nothing serious or gamebreaking. Usually just someone vibrating a little lmfao, or the occasional body getting clipped in a wall.
Performance is a little rough (with an RTX 3070 + Ryzen 9 3900X I get ~60 FPS on high 1440p), but load times are really good via my SSD, and havenāt had any crashes or anything. Iām happy with the visuals, and the face animations seem fine to me (Iāve seen some people say they trigger the uncanny valley for them).
On a side note:
Started Baldurās Gate 3 today. Iāve heard good things about it, but it just didnāt seem like my type of game.
Two hours in, and, while it has taken a lot of getting used to, I like it. I havenāt played many traditional CRPGs, or many turn based RPGs at all. The freedom is really neat though, and I do feel like I can do pretty much anything.
The visuals, voice acting, and dialogue are all impressive as well.
The same thing is happening here with Starfield in a different direction haha. Too many people expecting endless and interesting procedural worlds, while somehow also being an RPG with 100+ hours of story contentā¦